Skip to content

Jalisco: let us not admit impediments

27 January 2016

Love is not love, which alters where it alteration finds… except in the 26 states where same-sex marriages … while legal… still require one to obtain an amparo from the federal courts.  Although the Supreme Court definitively ruled that same-sex marriages are a constitutional right, and the court can (and did) order the states to change their marriage laws to meet constitutional standards, it has only limited power to force them to do so.  And, for historical reasons, “state’s rights” in constitutional matters are difficult to overcome. While the ruling is binding on all federal courts, and the Supreme Court can tell the states to change their marriage laws, it can’t force them to do so.  UNLESS… there are at least five rulings by federal courts within the state finding the law unconstitutional.

While in a few states, the legislatures have simply accepted that they need to change their marriage laws, the rest — to avoid the hassle, or to give cover to politicians scared to death to actually take a not-particularly controversial stand — are trying to shift the burden for making changes to the federal courts. Federal courts will automatically follow the Supreme Court’s ruling, and grant an “amparo” (injunction) for same-sex couples to marry.  So, in theory, a same-sex couple can marry anywhere in Mexico… provided they can invest the time, money, and energy into filing for an amparo.   Although there are any number of organizations and individuals working to bring same sex marriage cases to the federal courts, it’s a slow process.

But in Jalisco, the process has been short-circuited.  While Puerto Vallarta may be a “gay mecca” and Guadalajara might show a modernist facade, the state was the heartland of the Cristero movement and has been notoriously reactionary.  When the Federal District opened marriage to same-sex couples, Jalisco’s legislature was quick to pass a “one man-one woman” marriage law… too quick, it turns out.

Having overlooked the age at which one can marry, the state legislature had to revisit their marriage law and tweak it.  Little noticed, and uncontroversial in itself, the change did open a window of opportunity for lawyers to question the constitutionality of what was in effect a new marriage law passed after the Supreme Court’s ruling.  And for the Supreme Court to make Jalisco the sixth state (including the Federal District, which is becoming a state) to those places in Mexico that joined the 21st century.






2 Comments leave one →
  1. pablothemexican permalink
    27 January 2016 5:58 am

    “…that joined the 21st century….”

    That has joined Satan in his “Nonserviam” in Hell is what the article should conclude.

    Jews, Freemasonry, Gnosticism, and so on are still in open rebellion against God.

    By turning souls away from Our Lord, these groups have made ignorant peasants of souls that once knew our purpose is to know, love, and serve God.

    For your consideration:

    Under the image of San Miguel Archangel, is an article that outlines what all well catechized Catholics should know. (This image stands upon El Cerrito de Tepeyac in Mexico City).

    Santa María de Guadalupe Esperanza nuestra, salva nuestra patria y conserva nuestra Fe.


  2. DonAlbertoDoyle permalink
    29 January 2016 2:28 pm

    And the reply above is exactly why we need the courts and legislatures to remind people, legally and juridically, why their various Bronze Age voodoo fetishes, and books badly written by shoeless Levant goatherds three millennia, ago shall have no relevance to the rest of civilization living under a secular Constitution in the 21st Century, CE. N.B., CE. No reference in modern year-dating to some scrawny dead dude who wore a dress and only hung out with other dudes, one of whom verse after verse describes as his one special love, and in any case for whom there’s not a shred of historical evidence.

    If there was a Jesus, he was clearly gay.

Leave a reply, but please stick to the topic

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: